5 Best Italian Restaurants in Fishers, Indiana to Try

Fishers, Indiana, a vibrant suburb of Indianapolis, is not just known for its family-friendly community and scenic parks but also for its burgeoning food scene.

Italian cuisine enthusiasts will find a delightful array of eateries offering delicious, authentic dishes.

From cozy trattorias to elegant dining spots, here are the five best Italian restaurants in Fishers that you absolutely must try.

Sangiovese Ristorante

Sangiovese Ristorante at Fishers District is a local favorite known for its sophisticated ambiance and exceptional Italian dishes.

Start your meal with the Burrata Antipasti, featuring creamy burrata cheese paired with fresh tomatoes and basil, drizzled with olive oil.

The Osso Buco is a standout entrée, featuring tender veal shank braised to perfection and served over a bed of risotto Milanese.

For dessert, the Tiramisu is an absolute must-try, with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and rich mascarpone cream.

I Tre Mori

I Tre Mori offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and a menu filled with traditional Italian favorites.

Their Pappardelle Bolognese is a highlight, with wide, hand-cut noodles coated in a rich and savory meat sauce.

Another must-try is the Margherita Pizza, featuring fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil leaves on a perfectly crispy crust.

For a sweet finish, try their Chocolate Lava Cake, which oozes decadent chocolate when you cut into it.

Portofino

Portofino is renowned for its authentic Italian-inspired cuisine, making every meal feel like a trip to Italy.

Begin with the Calamari Fritti, lightly breaded and fried to golden perfection, served with marinara sauce.

The Lobster Ravioli, filled with succulent lobster meat and paired with a rich, creamy sauce, is highly recommended.

Don’t miss their Cannoli for dessert; this traditional Italian pastry is filled with a sweet ricotta cheese mixture and sprinkled with chocolate chips.

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is a charming spot known for its thick-crust pizzas and unique deep dish options.

The Deep Dish Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try, featuring layers of gooey cheese and spicy pepperoni in a perfectly baked crust.

For pasta lovers, the Oven-Baked Lasagna offers layers of pasta, meat sauce, and melted cheese that are simply irresistible.

End your visit with their house-made Gelato, available in various flavors that change seasonally.

The Italian House on Park

The Italian House on Park in nearby Carmel is worth the short drive for its elegant setting and exquisite dishes.

Their Parmesan-Crusted Sea Bass is a standout, featuring fresh fish baked with a crispy Parmesan crust and served with a side of risotto.

Try the Gnocchi Gorgonzola, which offers tender potato gnocchi in a creamy Gorgonzola sauce.

The Espresso Panna Cotta is an exceptional dessert, combining the rich flavor of espresso with the creamy texture of panna cotta.