5 Best Italian Restaurants in Elgin, Illinois to Try

Elgin, Illinois, may be known for its vibrant history and picturesque Fox River views, but it also offers a delectable array of Italian cuisine that any food lover would appreciate.

From cozy, family-owned establishments to trendy, modern eateries, Elgin’s Italian dining scene brings authentic flavors and memorable experiences. Here are the five best Italian restaurants in Elgin that you absolutely must try.

Cafe Roma

Cafe Roma is a beloved local gem known for its comforting, home-style Italian dishes and friendly atmosphere.

Start with their Farfalle Creamy Garlic Con Pollo, a delightful dish of bow-tie pasta in a rich garlic cream sauce with tender chicken.

The Shrimp Diavolo is another must-try, featuring succulent shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce served over perfectly cooked pasta.

Don’t miss their Classic Caesar Salad, which offers fresh romaine, crunchy croutons, and tangy Caesar dressing.

For a sweet finish, enjoy the traditional Tiramisu, layered with mascarpone cheese and espresso-soaked ladyfingers.

Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria

Maciano’s Pizza & Pastaria delivers hearty portions and comforting Italian classics in a welcoming setting.

Their Deep Dish Pizza is an absolute must-try, loaded with sausage and extra mushrooms that satisfy every pizza lover’s craving.

Another favorite is the Chicken Parmigiana, with a crisp breaded chicken breast smothered in marinara and melted mozzarella.

For pasta enthusiasts, the Fettuccine Alfredo offers a creamy, garlicky delight that pairs beautifully with their house-made garlic bread.

Finish your meal with their Giant Homemade Tiramisu, a larger-than-life version of the beloved dessert.

Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano

Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano combines an upscale yet relaxed atmosphere with a menu full of traditional Italian flavors.

Start with the Spaghetti Marinara, featuring perfectly cooked pasta nestled in a delicious, house-made tomato sauce.

The Lobster Corn Chowder is a decadent option, blending fresh lobster with creamy corn chowder for a rich, savory soup.

For a standout entrée, try the Chicken Marsala—tender chicken breasts in a flavorful Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.

End your visit with the Lemon Tower Cake, a light and refreshing dessert that’s a perfect palate cleanser.

Riganato Old World Grille

Riganato Old World Grille offers a charming, rustic ambiance and a menu that emphasizes fresh, high-quality ingredients.

Their Italian Beef Sandwich is a local favorite, featuring thinly sliced beef in a savory au jus sauce on a crispy roll.

Try the Penne Rustica Chix for a comforting pasta dish loaded with tender chicken and vegetables in a creamy tomato sauce.

For seafood lovers, the Shrimp Scampi delivers perfectly sautéed shrimp in garlic butter over angel hair pasta.

Wash it all down with a glass of their house-made Sangria, which offers a refreshing complement to any meal.

Giostra By Fabio Viviani

Giostra By Fabio Viviani brings a modern twist to traditional Italian dishes, all crafted by celebrity chef Fabio Viviani.

The Burrata Caprese Salad, with its creamy burrata, fresh tomatoes, and basil, is a delightful way to start your meal.

Their Gnocchi Al Forno, baked with a blend of cheeses and marinara, is a comforting and indulgent dish that melts in your mouth.

For a heartier option, try the Osso Buco, a braised veal shank served with a rich and flavorful sauce.

End your dining experience with a slice of Pistachio Gelato Cake, a unique and delicious dessert that combines creamy gelato with crunchy pistachios.