Ulysses S. Grant’s Most Famous Quote Was Born at This 1862 Tennessee Fort Siege

Fort Donelson, Tennessee

In February 1862, a young Union general named Ulysses S. Grant shocked the Confederate Army with two simple words that would echo through history. When asked for terms of surrender at Fort Donelson, Grant’s blunt reply changed everything.

Here’s how one brutal winter battle in Tennessee launched Grant toward greatness.

The Strategic Cumberland River Position

Confederate leaders knew the Cumberland River cut like a knife through Tennessee straight to Nashville. Any Union gunboats passing Fort Donelson could strike at the state capital.

Eleven big guns sat 100 feet above the water. The fort’s main weapon, a massive 128-pounder, could smash wooden boats to splinters.

A three-mile ring of trenches and earthworks protected the fort from land attack. Rifle pits lined the ridges where soldiers could fire down on approaching enemies.

After losing Fort Henry on February 6, Johnston rushed reinforcements to Fort Donelson. He knew both forts must hold or Nashville would fall.

Grant’s Army Marches from Fort Henry

Grant moved on Fort Donelson immediately after taking Fort Henry. He promised his superiors he would capture the fort by February 8, but nature had other plans.

Winter storms turned roads into mud pits. Soldiers slogged through freezing slush while waiting for more troops and supplies.

On February 12, the Union army finally began its 12-mile march. Forrest’s Confederate horsemen struck the columns repeatedly throughout the day.

By February 13, Grant had surrounded the western side of the fort with 25,000 men. His troops tested the Confederate defenses with small attacks before planning the main assault.

The Powerful Confederate Command

John B. Floyd arrived February 11 to command Fort Donelson. A politician with minimal military experience, Floyd had served as Secretary of War under President Buchanan before the conflict.

Gideon Pillow and Simon Buckner came to assist Floyd. Pillow had a spotty record from the Mexican War, while Buckner brought professional West Point training.

Nathan Bedford Forrest led the cavalry at Fort Donelson. Unlike the other commanders, Forrest rose from private to colonel without formal education.

Nearly 17,000 Confederates packed the fort by February 13. Their numbers seemed strong enough to hold off Grant’s army.

Poor communication and conflicting goals plagued the Southern leaders throughout the battle.

The Ironclads Meet the River Batteries

February 14 broke cold and silent. That afternoon, Union Flag Officer Foote brought his gunboat fleet up the Cumberland River to hammer Fort Donelson.

Four ironclad warships led the attack – St. Louis, Pittsburgh, Louisville, and Carondelet. These armored vessels had crushed Fort Henry days earlier.

Two wooden gunboats backed them up. Confederate gunners waited until the fleet came within range. Their elevated position let them hit vulnerable spots on the Union boats.

The river battle raged for over an hour. Southern guns damaged all four ironclads and wounded Foote himself. Confederate soldiers cheered as they watched the battered ships withdraw downstream.

The Desperate Confederate Breakout

Confederate commanders realized Grant would soon cut off all escape routes. At dawn on February 15, they launched a surprise attack to punch through Union lines toward Nashville.

Pillow led the main assault against the Union right flank. Thousands of Southern troops surged forward in the freezing morning air.

Union forces fell back under the onslaught. By mid-morning, Confederate troops cleared the road to Nashville and freedom seemed within reach.

Just as victory seemed certain, Floyd ordered his men back to the fort instead of continuing the escape. This fatal decision closed their only route to freedom.

Grant’s Decisive Counterattack

Grant returned from meeting with the wounded Foote to find his right flank broken. Rather than retreat, he spotted opportunity in the Confederate pullback.

He noticed Southern soldiers carried full knapsacks during their attack. This told him they planned to escape rather than just fight.

Grant told General Smith, “All has failed on our right—you must take Fort Donelson.” Smith, a tough old soldier who once taught Grant at West Point, simply answered, “I will do it.”

Smith personally led his men forward, riding through enemy fire to inspire his troops. By nightfall, Union forces had not only recovered lost ground but captured part of the Confederate outer works.

The Night of Desperate Decisions

Confederate leaders gathered at the Dover Inn on the bitter night of February 15. The meeting quickly revealed deep splits among the commanders.

Buckner argued their position was hopeless. Grant would attack at dawn, leading to unnecessary bloodshed. Floyd refused to surrender.

As former Secretary of War, he feared being tried for treason if captured. Pillow insisted they try another breakout. Forrest declared firmly he would never surrender his men.

As temperatures dropped, so did Southern hopes.

The Cowardly Escape of Floyd and Pillow

Floyd handed command to Pillow, who immediately passed it to Buckner. This command shuffle let Floyd and Pillow justify abandoning their men.

Floyd escaped across the river with his Virginia troops during the night. They used the few available boats to flee, leaving thousands behind.

Pillow slipped away with Floyd in the darkness. Neither general would hold important command again after this disgraceful act.

Forrest led 700 cavalrymen through frozen swamps along the river, finding a path not yet blocked by Union troops. About 3,000 Confederates escaped before surrender, and the remaining 12,000 woke to see white flags flying over their fort.

Grant’s Unconditional Surrender Demand

On February 16, Buckner sent a note to Grant requesting surrender terms. He expected reasonable conditions from Grant, whom he considered a friend from their pre-war army service.

Years earlier, when Grant resigned from the army and faced financial ruin, Buckner had loaned him money to return home.

Grant’s response stunned Buckner: “No terms except unconditional and immediate surrender can be accepted.

Northern newspapers soon dubbed him “Unconditional Surrender Grant,” turning his initials “U.S.” into a fitting nickname.

The Devastating Confederate Defeat

Buckner surrendered Fort Donelson on February 16, 1862. Grant captured about 12,000 Confederate troops, the largest capture of enemy forces in American history to that point.

The South lost not just soldiers but 48 cannons, 17 heavy guns, and mountains of supplies they couldn’t replace. Union casualties reached 2,691 men—507 killed, 1,976 wounded, and 208 captured or missing.

Confederate losses totaled nearly 14,000, with most taken prisoner. This marked the first of three entire Confederate armies Grant would capture during the war.

Church bells rang across Northern cities as citizens celebrated this crucial early victory.

Visiting Fort Donelson National Battlefield

Fort Donelson National Battlefield protects the fort’s earthworks, river batteries, and battlefield grounds.

The Dover Hotel is still here, the two-story brick building where Buckner formally surrendered to Grant.

You can find the main entrance at 120 Fort Donelson Park Road in Dover, Tennessee.

Read More on WhenInYourState.com:

• Thieves Steal Plaques from Chattanooga Military Park, Drove Green Ford F-150
• 13 Best Things to Do in Tennessee
• Here are 15 Best Things to do in Crossville, Tennessee